Johannes Chiang氏からのご回答 Reply from Professor Johannes Chiang ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 回答の順番が逆になっておりますが、原文のまま抽出させていた頂きました。 現地でのトラブルが原因で間に合わなかったとのことです。 尚、質問は下記の通りでした。 1) Concerning new gTLDs; How do you think ICANN should incorporate various opinions? Do you have any ideas regarding its policy? 2)It seems that organized election campaign has been held in Asia such as in Japan and in China. Do you support this kind of acitivity or not? 3) Concerning multiligual domain; Do you have any opinion regarding the introduction of multilingual domain names? What is your specific plan as a ICANN director to deal with the multilingual domian names? 4)It is generally said that the total number of gTLD registration is more than 20 million, while that of ccTLD registration is 6 million. The number of gTLD or other new TLD seems to increase continually as the new TLD are introduced by ICANN. Do you think any measure is needed to enhance registration and use of ccTLD? <メール本文>ここより +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Subject: [JPNIC ig-sg-ml 5] Re: Internet Governance Study Session From: "Johannes Chiang" < chi@mis.nccu.edu.tw > To: < ig-sg-ml@nic.ad.jp > Date: Wed, 6 Sep 2000 13:53:20 +0800 Reply-To: ig-sg-ml@nic.ad.jp X-Mailer: Microsoft Outlook Express 5.00.2615.200 Dear all, The following states my opinions to your questions: 2. It seems that organized election campaign has been held in Asia such as in Japan and in China. Do you support this kind of acitivity or not? Ans: Absolutely not. I've heard of this for sometime. But, we must also say, we don't have any evidences about this until now. So, I like to say, don't let it happen, and I need your votes in this election. 1. Concerning new gTLDs; How do you think ICANN should incorporate various opinions? > Do you have any ideas regarding its policy? Ans: As you can read in my document, I support to increase gTLD without "unneccessary" restrictions. From the technical point of view, to increase gTLD means a test to the stability and scalability of our exsiting DNS. And, it takes time to have the new gTLD funtioning in a fine way. From a socialogical point of view, which new gTLD should we increase is a problematcis of consensus. For instance, many told me we should devide .com into new gTLDs and may have a ".sme" (for small and meddle sized enterprises). On the other hand, I also know that many SMEs don't like this idea. I believe that we could increse gTLD but must evaluate in what number could we do in one time, i.e. the stability of exsisting DNS and functionality of the new one are the most important critierien to help our decision. Secondly, we could determine which new gTLDs should at first be in process (priority) by vote or endorsement, and even by giving the new gTLDs a test period. I mean, if in a certain time just few people really apply a new gTLD, it should not run into the real-life process. (Sorry, I have to answer so long, as you know this is a complcated question. Please also feedback your opinions to me.) 3. Concerning multiligual domain; Do you have any opinion regarding the introduction of multilingual domain names? What is your specific plan as a ICANN director to deal with the multilingual domian names? Ans: Multilingual domain names could be bery helpful for those who do not know English to enter the Internet world, at least they could communicate with their those who speak the same language. Naturally, if we want the MDN run globally, we are facing the facit of translation machanism. This is a crucial issue. I have worked for a multilingual document management system in Han-Character (Kanri) region. I know that even the same word in Japanese could have different meaning than in Chinese. As I know, there is already a cooperation connnecting the experts from China, Japan, Korea and Taiwan for the development of the M-DNS in the far-east. I will of course support their afforts and even work together with them. Last but not least, I believe that m-DNS should be at first developed by regional groups in which the members have the similiar langusges. More explicitly speaking, I think we should at first resolve the local problems, we have then the chances to resolve the global one. At least, m-DNS will facilitate the outreach of the Internet. 4)It is generally said that the total number of gTLD registration is more than 20 million, while that of ccTLD registration is 6 million. The number of gTLD or other new TLD seems to increase continually as the new TLD are introduced by ICANN. Do you think any measure is needed to enhance registration and use of ccTLD? Yes. I think Internet will run over the borden of nationality. Johannes Chiang +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++